Note: American Express is a Frequent Miler advertiser. Please see our Advertiser Disclosure.
Last week, Point Princess tweeted a request for me to update my Fair Trading Prices page. Done! It had been over a year since it was last updated and a lot has changed since then. Fair Trading Prices are per point estimates of how much money a person gives up by using a point or mile earning credit card instead of a no-fee 2% cash back card. For example, if a person puts all spend on a card that earns one point per dollar, then they are sacrificing 2 cents per dollar by using that card rather than a 2% cash back card. In other words, one can think of points earned with that card as costing 2 cents per dollar. Or, if a card earns 2 points per dollar, then each point costs 1 cent. In my Fair Trading Prices page, I used credit cards that offer the lowest cost per point for many types of points (bank points, airline miles, etc.) in order to calculate and display “Fair Trading Prices”.
With most credit cards, the calculations were a bit more complicated than described above. For cards with category bonuses, it was necessary to estimate how much spend would be put in these categories in order to estimate the average number of points earned per dollar. It was also necessary to take into account category spend caps, big-spend bonuses, etc. Towards that end, I created a Google Docs spreadsheet for estimating these values. And, the spreadsheet revealed some interesting findings. More on that further down the page…
Understanding Fair Trading Prices
Fair Trading Prices are not estimates of redemption value. Instead, they reflect the acquisition cost — the “going rate” for buying points, unwittingly, through credit card spend. If the chart says that the Fair Trading price for American Airlines miles is 1.73 cents, for example, this does not mean that you will get 1.73 cents of value from your miles when you redeem them. You may get much more value or you may get much less. However, if you are thinking about buying miles, acquiring miles via a shopping portal, or even putting spend on a miles earning credit card, the fair trading price is a reasonable number to use to estimate the worth of those miles.
Changes to Fair Trading Prices
There were several significant changes to the Fair Trading Prices since I last published an update about a year ago. Here are a few highlights:
- Annual Fees now included. Fair Trading Prices are now calculated not just from the opportunity cost of not using a 2% cash back card, but also from the point-earning card’s annual fee. This caused a number of Fair Trading Prices to increase.
- New cards included. The Amex EveryDay cards that were introduced in 2014 offer really good points per dollar earning potential. The addition of these cards caused a number of Fair Trading Prices to decrease.
- Category bonuses changed. A number of cards from Amex and Citibank have new or altered category bonuses, usually for the better. This has caused a number of Fair Trading Prices to decrease.
- Chase annual bonuses eliminated. The Sapphire Preferred card used to offer a 7% annual dividend. And, the Freedom card, when paired with a Chase checking account, used to offer a 10% annual bonus. Both of these bonuses are being eliminated going forward. As a result, I’ve removed them from the spreadsheet.
- Chase Freedom 5X bonuses calculated differently. The spreadsheet now assumes Chase Freedom will continue to have quarterly 5X category bonuses similar to the 2015 quarterly bonuses.
- Added hybrid Freedom/premium card options. With the assumptions currently in the spreadsheet, the Freedom card earns more points per dollar, on average, than any other Ultimate Rewards card. However, in order to transfer Ultimate Rewards to airline miles, it is necessary to have a premium card too, such as the Ink Plus or Sapphire Preferred. I modeled two scenarios: Freedom paired with Sapphire Preferred, and Freedom paired with Ink Plus. The results were nearly identical (the scenarios average 1.76 or 1.78 points per dollar, respectively). I used the Freedom / Sapphire Preferred combination to estimate the Fair Trading Price.
The factors listed above have caused some Fair Trading Prices to rise and others to drop. Here are some changes that stand out:
- Membership Rewards Fair Trading Price dropped from 1.29 to 1.00 (due to the high earning potential of EveryDay cards)
- British Airways dropped from 1.29 to 1.00 due to the Membership Rewards drop
- Delta dropped from 1.29 to 1.06 due to the Membership Rewards drop (the extra .06 comes from the extra fee to transfer MR to US based frequent flyer programs)
- Ultimate Rewards dropped slightly from 1.38 to 1.32
- SPG increased from 1.95 to 2.16, due to the inclusion of the card’s annual fee in the calculation
- Alaska, American, and Lufthansa increased from 1.56 to 1.73, due to the increase in the SPG Fair Trading Price
- All hotel estimates increased a bit due to the addition of annual fees
Hotel Fair Trading prices are calculated differently than bank points and airline miles. I could calculate them the same way (and I used to), but the problem is that earning hotel points from credit card spend, for many chains, is a really bad deal. With most chains (with a few exceptions), hotel points are usually worth much less than a penny each when redeemed for hotel stays. So, in most cases, you would actually be better off using a pathetic 1% cash back card than a hotel card if all it offers is 1 point per dollar for spend. And, of course, a 2% cash back card would be much better.
A couple of significant exceptions to this rule are SPG (Starwood Preferred Guest) and Hilton. With SPG, points are often actually worth quite a lot towards free nights. And, points can be transferred at a better than 1 to 1 ratio to airline miles when transferring 20,000 points at a time (20,000 SPG points typically transfer to 25,000 airline miles). So, the SPG card is a reasonable card to use for earning SPG points. Hilton points, on the other hand, are usually worth much less than a penny each, but credit card bonus categories make up for that. The Amex Hilton Honors Surpass card, for example, earns 12X at Hilton properties, 6X for dining, gas, and groceries, and 3X everywhere else.
Fair Trading Prices for SPG and Hilton are computed from credit card earnings with the same methodology as bank and airline miles above. The rest of the hotel values are computed relative to SPG and Hilton. The idea is that the usual way to earn other types of hotel points is through hotel stays rather than through credit card spend. And, therefore, we can calculate the cost of earning hotel points through stays by comparing to the points that would have been earned if one had stayed at SPG or Hilton properties instead. For example, if a hotel offers 5 times as many points for a stay as with SPG, then the fair trade price for that hotel using the SPG index is the SPG fair trading price divided by 5. For each hotel chain, two Fair Trading prices are calculated: the SPG Index and the Hilton Index. The chain’s Fair Trade Price, then, is the average of the two. For more details about this approach, please see this post.
Note that, in addition to SPG and Hilton, Club Carlson credit cards are a reasonable option for earning hotel points since they offer 5 points per dollar earnings across the board (and 10X at Club Carlson properties). The reason that the Club Carlson credit card wasn’t used for these calculations is that Club Carlson also offers a fantastic 20 points per dollar for hotel stays (and that’s before adding various bonuses they offer). As a result, the Club Carlson Fair Trading Price is lower when calculated relative to SPG and Hilton (.28 cents per point) than when calculated from credit card spend (.43 cents per point). So, I went with the lower number.
Best point earning cards
As a result of updating the spreadsheet used for these calculations, I found that a few credit cards really stood out from the pack with respect to their point-earning potential:
- The Amex EveryDay Preferred card averages a whopping 2.33 points per dollar! Note that this is dependent upon making 30 purchases each billing cycle with the card to trigger the card’s 50% bonus.
- The Amex Premier Rewards Gold card, with its new categories as of June 1 2015, averages 1.75 points per dollar
- The no-fee Ink Cash card at 1.55 points per dollar edges out the $95/year Ink Plus card at 1.39 points per dollar. The cards’ bonus categories are mostly the same except that the Ink Cash earns 2X for restaurants whereas the Ink Plus earns 2X at hotels. The spreadsheet assumes much more spend at restaurants than at hotels.
- The no-fee Chase Freedom card averages 1.6 points per dollar.
- The Citi ThankYou Premier card averages an excellent 1.85 cents per dollar based on new categories that start April 19th (3X travel and gas, 2X dining and entertainment).
- The US Bank FlexPerks Travel Rewards American Express card averages a very respectable 1.64 points per dollar. Points can be worth up to 2 cents per point when used for travel, so averaging 1.64 is really good! The Amex version of this card beats out the Visa version because the Amex version includes 2X dining whereas the Visa version does not.
- The Club Carlson and Amex Hilton Honors Surpass cards average over 5 points per dollar. Keep in mind, though, that hotel points (other than SPG and Hyatt) tend to be worth much less than a penny each towards stays, so while these earning rates really are very good, they should not be compared to earning rates for bank points or airline miles.
It’s important to note that my spreadsheet results were based on a number of assumptions that probably are not true for you:
- I estimated the percent of spend that would be in various categories (e.g. 20% dining, 25% grocery, etc.)
- I estimated that spend would total $30,000 per year
- I made the assumption that this one card would be used for all spend.
Feel free to make a copy of the spreadsheet in order to alter the assumptions to fit your situation.