Surviving the last day CVS scramble

This is it.  Today is the day…

VanillaReloadScramble

Today (April 3rd) is the last day to buy reload cards at CVS (with a credit card)

Incase you’ve been hiding in a cave, I should mention that the rumor of CVS going cash only for reload cards is true.  The only slightly false part of the rumor was the date.  Yes, some CVS stores went cash only on 3/31, but most of the country is going cash only on April 4th (Friday).  What to do?  Run out today to your favorite CVS store, then read this when you get home: 9 ways to cope without reload cards.

Swipe reloads at at CVS

Before the fateful CVS memo was leaked, I thought I had found something fabulous.  Do you remember how I said that you can “swipe reload” Amex Serve cards at the register at CVS?  Well, I found out that you can do the same with almost all Vanilla Reloadables (one exception I found is the Bluebird card that has stayed faithful to Walmart).  So, bring in a stack of Vanilla Reloadables (MyVanilla, NetSpend, JH Preferred, etc.) and load them each up one at a time at the register, up to $500 per transaction.  Simply hand the cashier your reloadable card and say  you would like to reload your prepaid card (say “please” too).  Other than Serve which is free, you will be charged a $3.95 fee per transaction.  It’s basically just like buying Vanilla Reload cards except that it doesn’t matter whether or not the reload cards are in stock (and guess what, they’re probably not in stock today).  Unfortunately, swipe reloads are going cash only too.  So, you have today only to try out this trick (sorry).

Finding cards where they’re not supposed to be

If Swipe Reloads aren’t enough to keep you busy today, you’ll probably make your way over to the gift card rack to look for your favorite reload cards.  And, they won’t be there.  After all, everyone else in the world has been scrambling to buy them before April 4th, so it should come as no surprise that they’re sold out.  Or, are they….?  Grab random piles of other gift cards and fan them out.  If you’re lucky, you’ll find some that were previously hidden there by others.  If you find more than you plan to buy, do the next customer a favor by leaving the extras exposed.  After all, they won’t do you any good after today!

8PM EST deadline: Today!

Amol, at Hack My Trip tells us that CVS computers switch over to “the next day” at 8PM EST each evening (see “The Reports of Vanilla Reload’s Demise Have Not Been Exaggerated“).  So, if you’re reading this on April 3rd, you have just until 8PM EST / 5PM Pacific to use your credit cards to earn points and miles at CVS.  Hey, I’m just the messenger.  Blame Amol if you don’t get there in time.

What about load-once MasterCard/Visa gift cards?

The memos stating that CVS was going cash only refer specifically to reloadable cards.  So, it might still be possible to buy load-once gift cards such as OneVanilla.  The problem is that I doubt managers and cashiers will understand the difference.  So, I expect it will be hard to buy just about anything of value at CVS for a while.  We’ll see.

About Greg The Frequent Miler

Greg is the owner, founder, and primary author of the Frequent Miler. He earns millions of points and miles each year, mostly without flying, and dedicates this blog to teaching others how to do the same.

More articles by Greg The Frequent Miler »

55
Leave a Reply

avatar
33 Comment threads
22 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
31 Comment authors
Manufacturing spend with Serve - Frequent MilerBluebird vs. Serve once againkahnSeattle Points and Miles - The Frequent Milerluchex Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
Notify of
Amol (@PointsToPointB)
Guest

Whoa whoa whoa, no blaming me either 😛

That’s just when the “day” resets. My CVSs in So Cal already are hard blocked as of 4/2 so game over (VR at least) for me 🙁

danny
Guest
danny

I was able to purchase one around 8pm pst in so cal

JAT
Guest
JAT

Just a thought;
Why I believe it might have been the Citi AAdvantage Exec CC (100,000 miles) that prompted CVS from going cash only on VR.

How would you like to be the person in CVS to wake up one morning only to realize CVS (maybe) owes $12 million to Credit Card company in 2 month!

Here are my thoughts, with so many of us signing up for AA Exec 100K miles Credit Card within the last 2 month and some of us (my self include) getting 2 AA Exec card. Many of us went out and bought VR as fast as we can.

Including all the normal CC purchasing VR at CVS and now this $10K min spend CC in the mix, I think CVS might have saw a huge upswing in VR purchases.

I created a table for a quick illustration. Disclaimer: I DO NOT have any inside information on how much CVS pays out to Credit Card companies or Vanilla Reload network in selling VR cards. This is only to illustrate the point. Based on how many new AA Credit card might have been open; 50K to 100K new CC within last 2 month

No of New AA CC 50,000 75,000 100,000
Mim Spend $10,000 $10,000 $10,000
CVS Tot Transaction $500M $750M $1B
CVS Profit ($3.95) $3.95M $5.922M $7.9M

CC Payout – 1% $5M $7.5M $10M
CVS Loss @ 1% Payout -$1.05M -$1.575M -$2.1M

CC Payout – 1.5% $7.5M $11.25M $15M
CVS Loss@ 1.5% Payout -$3.55M -$5.325M -$7.1M

CC Payout – 2% $10M $ $15M $20M
CVS Loss@ 2% Payout -$6.05M -$9.075M -$12.1M

Such a huge payout to Credit Card companies by CVS in such a short time might have brought into light the money losing aspect of VR cards with Credit Card transaction.

I for one am sad this has happened but it is what it is.

Brian
Guest
Brian

VR’s are dead because two guys from Queens racked up 500k in VR purchases using fraudulent Capital One cards (http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2014/03/2_ny_men_tried_to_run_up_500k_in_fraudulent_charges_at_borgata_authorities_sayd.html)

David
Guest
David

Can the AMEX Prepaid card (blue in color) be swipe loaded? Is it any card that may be loaded using a VR card?

Jonathan
Guest
Jonathan

“Blame Amol if you don’t get there in time.”

LOL. Pesky bloggers. Killing all the deals and making me late too!

Awesome clip art. I see your Photoshop skills have improved, young grasshoppa!

William Charles
Guest

Mine are already hardcoded, I never realized that you could swipe existing cards you held, interesting learning all of these little tidbits!

Lynn
Guest
Lynn

Swiped my Serve at 6:30 last night, went in at 7:00 am this morning and the register said “cash only.” No signs in store and the manager seemed confused by the change. He let me try my Suntrust debit card, but that was refused also. Boo!

Geoff
Guest
Geoff

Nice artwork.

Douglas
Guest
Douglas

The Vanilla Reload Website lists other retailers who sell the VR cards… Have they (Walgreen’s, Dollar General, etc) already blocked purchases with credit cards??

chimmy
Guest
chimmy

And I just started in the game a couple weeks ago 🙁

Curtis
Guest
Curtis

Seriously doubt that 8PM cutoff. I was able to buy VRs at 11pm CT on 4/1 here in DFW. The next morning at 7am was not able to.

Jonathan
Guest
Jonathan

You have not understood the GMT cutoff correctly. If you bought 5k of VR’s at 11pm central time, that is 4AM GMT (4 hours after the reset already took place). So it then follows that you wont be able to buy another 5k until 7PM central of the following day.

Go here (http://www.worldtimebuddy.com/) and add the “GMT” time zone as one of the rows. Midnight on the “GMT” row is the only one you should compare to and care about. That just happens to be 8pm eastern, but don’t let that confuse you. Compare your time with GMT. Midnight in GMT time is what matters.

Greg, keep in mind the GMT reset is when people are able to buy vanilla reloads again. It does not necessarily mean that is when the “cash-only” cut-off will happen. Since the cut-off is regional, its entirely possible that they are rolling out the changes at midnight. Thats just speculation on my part but id advise your readers to try between 8pm EST and 12am tonight if they are really desperate to try to get one last scoop of ice cream. As for me, I’ve maxed out WF and met all my minimum spends already.

Curtis
Guest
Curtis

@Johnathan. I know about the midnight GMT reset for $5k. I’m not talking about that, nor was FM. This time the registers are updated (with new software)… I.E. the time that your CVS becomes a “brick” (to compare to a dead phone or other device).

Geoff
Guest
Geoff

Tried at 8 am today. No luck.
RIP; VR’s.
Onward to VISA debits/PINS, Wally World.
Sigh.

Ben
Guest
Ben

Not VR related, and I may have missed a post. I have a Citi Thank You Preferred (ie not Premier), and I was mailed an offer to sign up to receive 5x on gas, groceries and pharmacies between now and 6/30. Needed to activate. Is that something other people have been receiving?

Dave
Guest
Dave

Ben, is there a cap on how much 5x you can receive? Most people who signed up for the Citi TYPref last year did so with 5x bonus for 12 months, no limit. Citi will periodically give bonuses for 3 months, but they’re always capped. For example, my Citi AA (not 100K one) will get me 3x on drug stores and 3 other irrelevant categories, but capped at $1250 spending.

Ben
Guest
Ben

Good point, it is capped. I don’t have the details in front of me but if I recall correctly it is similar to the Freedom ($1,500), I was wondering if they were going to go towards a rotating categories model, but it does not sound like it’s the case. I am a bit worried about their tracking system for categories, as I went to the butcher and the category was “frozen good”, hopefully I won’t regret it (I also have the Blue Cash Preferred, so I am saving some of the $6,000 for later in the year by taking this 5x).

mike f
Guest
mike f

Bought 2 last night around 9 pm at 2 different stores in Orlando, will try again today as I have some spend to work through.

chuck
Guest
chuck

Regarding the little hidden secrets coming out into the open: I have held that there are many many of these. Unless you have someone inform you or you accidently run into one, most readers will never know. FM, who has almost unlimited access to these secrets, selectively chooses whether it will be published in his blog. Some happen only once the game ends, they are found out belatedly. Naturally that is his choice, it is his blog. I have noticed over the past couple years that he is more selective than at first in releasing this information publicly. His quest to help his readers find the perpetual system has morphed somewhat and diminished.

Jerry Mandel
Guest
Jerry Mandel

Again and again and again, One Vanilla (non-reloadable) is not a gift card; it is a debit card.

JustSaying
Guest
JustSaying

Although I had cleaned out the shelf on Sunday night my NoCal CVS had 10k left last night at 8pm after another locust run………South Florida still has Circle K gas but you must be very very patient with them as they use a separate machine to validate the cards and then the cash register transaction……..I will forever love CVS and will someday have this as a great story to tell my grandkids………..

Lively
Guest
Lively

You’re a riot.

Jesson
Guest
Jesson

Just found it on the web, even Hitler is furious about the CVS news: http://captiongenerator.com/14754/Hitler-Rips-CVS-for-Vanilla-Reload-Masacre

Max
Guest
Max

I had a wonderful cashier at one CVS last night. She sold me 5K worth of vr’s despite the other cashiers waving the memo at her and complaining to some manager on the phone. She just told them to buzz off, “this is our regular customer”. ☺

Curtis
Guest
Curtis

@Ben & FM, for the Citi TY 5x promo, there is a max of 2500 points, or $500. Lame…. My father got that offer but I got one for 2x (lame-er….)

JustSaying
Guest
JustSaying

Excuse my ignorance but should I expect the cc option to work in San Francisco tonight up until 859pm? BTW there are still some out there? My CVS manager laughed last night as I cleared another cc and asked “what will I do once this ends? Well I’ll watch the gift card rack as the poor VR cries out “Why won’t somebody buy me? I need some love”……………A sad day in history indeed!

JohnnieD
Guest
JohnnieD

Just got a VR at a gas station and it will not load to BB. The VR people told me on the phone that there is nothing wrong on their end, that I should call BB (oh no,not the offshore call center again…)

Called BB and rep told me they are having “issues with web reload at this time”. Um, ok, when can I reload my acct with VR then? “oh maybe 4 or 5 hrs from now”.

OK, I wait, I guess… Anybody else having VR to BB issues?? I had no issues loading gc’s at wm right before this (different BB acct….)

JohnnieD
Guest
JohnnieD

Just an update… 4 hrs later I loaded the VR…crisis over…

JustSaying
Guest
JustSaying

It is cathartic to know a mad dash to do the funeral load is crashing the phone lines…………this situation calls for alcohol consumption in copious amounts………

luchex
Guest
luchex

Couldn’t load VR either of the 2 BB we use .

Tony M
Guest
Tony M

CVS would not accept my cc for VR cards today. I’m in Harrisburg, PA.

CL
Guest
CL

It’s officially over. All the cvs registers on mkt street are hard coded to decline once serve is swiped. I tried 3 different serve cards. They all showed me the declined message. Then she showed me all the vanilla reloads they had hanging on the rack. She said someone tried this morning and it’s cash only….

Yesterday the mgr said the change is not due to cc fees… It’s due to cc theft and reload fraud. Cash will cut this down.

Oh and I like your captcha…

JustSaying
Guest
JustSaying

Market St SF?

Lord Advantine
Guest
Lord Advantine

Market St CVS seems to be sold out when I checked.

I usually go to the CVS on California St near the Ferry Building, and those are cash only too for VR.

JustSaying
Guest
JustSaying

Extremely interesting at CVS at BonAir in Marin, CA……….Woman has greeting card and $500 Visa gift card purchase…….she pays with credit card and departs
I start a $3000 purchase of VR…….first card scans in…….second card scans in and asks for driver’s license……driver’s license scans in……..third card causes pop up on screen to say “Cash Tender only”
Now I won’t be buying my VISA gift cards at CVS but for some of you that have drugstore 5X this might be of interest as it seems the same hardwire that killed VR has not killed a $500 Visa gift card………

Lord Advantine
Guest
Lord Advantine

The Vanilla Reload is dead, Long Live the Vanilla Gift Card!

mike f
Guest
mike f

Went 1 for 2 at tonight, first store no problem, second stroe I was told Cash opnly and then was allowed to see the memo/email, many other cards were also listed as cash only now, the first line of the memo mentioned the huge increase in CC processing fees… Will try again tomorrow at the good store. I am in Orlando,FL.

Peter
Guest
Peter

Luckily to get 4 Ice Cream cards using CC in one Tampa store around 8:30EST.

luchex
Guest
luchex

Completelly unrelated
Has anybody had problems loading BB using GC from GCmall using the moneymachine?
Today I had 4 GC , 1 OV 2 Visas I ordered from GCM and other Visa I bought at the store but it is commercialized by GCM. The 3 from GCM were rejected by the Money Machine.

trackback

[…] buying Vanilla Reload cards with credit cards to load Bluebird and then pay bills.  Now that CVS has gone cash-only, some of the content of the conference became more applicable to those who attended from nearby […]

kahn
Guest
kahn

i bought a couple of visa gift cards off my cc at rite aid with no trouble (they didnt mix it up with the reloads)

trackback

[…] was all fine and good until CVS went cash-only.  Now its no longer possible to pay with a credit card at CVS for Vanilla Reload cards (to reload […]

trackback

[…] perpetual point machine (PPM)… except for the “perpetual” part.  That PPM died in April 2014 when CVS decided to accept cash-only for most reloadable […]