Miles to Memories is reporting on what sounds like has been an extended outage at gift card resale site Gift Card Mart. A message at the top of the Gift Card Mart site notes that they are temporarily unable to buy or sell gift cards, and according to the comments at Miles to Memories this has lasted for quite some time. It may be a temporary outage — that’s what Gift Card Mart is saying — but the outage is obviously a cause for concern.
Shawn reached out to the owner of Gift Card Mart for a statement. See the Miles to Memories for the full statement, but here’s an excerpt:
We initially suspended customer gift card sales under the assumption that it was a short-term necessity while we fixed some underlying technical issues; however, after a few days, it became increasingly likely that the outage was going to take longer than expected.
Again, according to the comments, this situation has continued for several weeks already.
Gift card reselling was a huge avenue for manufactured spending for quite some time and those who were even remotely interested in that avenue as recently as about a year ago are no doubt familiar with the demise (disappearance?) of The Plastic Merchant and may find this news about Gift Card Mart concerning.
While I have known people who have sold to Gift Card Mart, I have never personally done business with them. I did get into TPM for a while and my gosh do I count my lucky stars for having the downright luck to have stopped when I did. Meeting folks who were much less fortunate on that really turned me off from gift card reselling, hence my lack of familiarity with Gift Card Mart. Truthfully, I’d thought about getting back into it a few times this year and Gift Card Mart is a site I’d have likely looked to get into if I had. At this point, I’m glad I held off.
Further details are slim at this point. There’s one comment at Miles to Memories from someone who claims to be owed a payment and another theorizing that the issue could be a cutoff from credit card payment processors. I’m sure there are plenty of other theories one could conjure — but it bears mentioning that it certainly could just be a technical issue as the owner of the site says.
However, I thought it was worth reporting this latest gift card resale issue for those who are considering testing those waters. It is a good reminder and warning not to get in over one’s head. While gift card resale can obviously be a good way to increase spend and earn rewards, you should take measures to mitigate your risk, one of which should be spreading it over multiple resale avenues. My lucky light bulb moment with TPM was when I realized that I was essentially handing over a large sum of cash (in the form of gift cards) to a stranger under the promise of being paid later (a blog commenter equated it to extending your credit to a stranger — almost like handing that person your credit card). That’s essentially what a merchandise re-seller is doing as well, and merchandise resale can certainly be a profitable and positive endeavor. Gift card resale no doubt can be as well — as long as it is done with reasonable precautions.
I hope that this issue at Gift Card Mart is temporary and I further hope that nobody has been or will be negatively impacted.
H/T: Miles to Memories
Want to learn more about miles and points? Subscribe to email updates or check out our podcast on your favorite podcast platform.
Still waiting… GCM. Coming back for Q4 or not?
[…] risk involved with gift card reselling, as seen last year with The Plastic Merchant and then over the last couple of months with GiftCardMart. Both of those are sites I’d sold to in the past and I lost some money with The Plastic […]
https://frequentmiler.com/gift-card-reselling-proceed-with-caution/#comment-2124543
Thought I remembered making a post about that during the TPM days.
This company always communicated well with me and paid me what I was owed, though I stopped selling gift cards about two years ago. From what I remember of speaking to their account reps their website was a constant battle for them, even years ago. Apparently it was initially created by a terrible programmer. So their website technical issues have been long running and wouldn’t surprise me. That said, I haven’t had contact with the company in years and have no real info about the current outage.
Gift Card Mart has always paid on my sell orders in the last 4 years. They were a little slow in December 2018, but eventually paid.
I would miss them if they didn’t come back. They were definitely a tool in my MS arsenal.
Wow, disappointing. Depending on the volume you do and whether you treat this as an actual business, you may want to purchase credit insurance from a commercial insurance broker.
The “technical problems” sounds like a millennial excuse for “good luck getting your money.”
You could also request a surety bond from the company . I doubt you’ll get that and it wouldn’t cover default for financial reasons.
If the company can’t get a surety bond you don’t want to deal with them
Giving thousands of dollars’ worth of negotiable instruments to some guy online who says he will pay you back at some time someday in the future. And you only make a couple percent. Or maybe lose 1%, but you’ll make it up on the points you earn. Think of the volume.
Strange how that might not work out. It’s a puzzlement.
Right. Any retailer accepting a credit card as form of payment is essentially doing the same thing, right? The money isn’t instantly in the retailer’s bank account. Chargebacks can happen. Anyone selling something incurs some risk.
You’re obviously not wrong and that is of course why I stopped doing it, but I think the model also can work.
Would I be correct that volume is key to making this work, so ebay is a waste of time?
You’re correct that volume is the key. Ebay is unideal for a number of reasons, but the two biggest ones are high fees and very customer-friendly (i.e. seller-unfriendly) policies. Five and a half months after the sale, the customer can say that the item wasn’t as described or wasn’t received (and the USPS would no longer have tracking info at that point if you had the foresight to send the physical card rather than just sending the card number in an email/ebay message). PayPal is infinitely more likely to side with the customer and give them their money back — which makes selling GCs on eBay not worth the risk. One scammer can wipe out the points for a large chunk of volume. That last sentence makes toomanybooks’s point that selling to one of these exchanges brings that same risk and with a lot of eggs in one basket. Like I said, I can’t argue that his logic is wrong. In an ideal world, it seems like there ought to be room for one of these exchanges to operate smoothly, but I’m sure that they deal with a lot of fraud, too — they are exposed to fraud on both sides of the coin (sellers and buyers), and perhaps that creates a cost of business that is too high in comparison to the margins.
It is not Gift card mall, it is Gift Card Mart
Thanks. Not sure why my fingers hit a double “l” a couple of times, but as the title, intro, and most of the body noted, it most certainly is Gift Card Mart that the post is about.
And I did fix those two typos — thanks again.