Does Chase 5/24 ruin my Hyatt Globalist plans?

Andaz Papagayo Sunrise

Sunset at the Andaz Papagayo Costa Rica Resort, a Hyatt property that charges 15,000 points per night.  Huge value from Hyatt: Andaz Peninsula Papagayo Costa Rica.

This year, for better or worse, I’ve left Hyatt behind in order to focus on achieving high level Marriott status (see: Marriott Platinum Premier: Into the home stretch).  And, next year I’ll be staying often at Marriott hotels in order to take advantage of temporary sweet spots that are available due to the Marriott / SPG merger.  In a few cases, I booked award stays in advance because the post-merger award prices were much higher.  For example, I’ve booked awards under old prices at the Westin Grand Cayman, Marriott’s Newport Coast Villas, and Domes of Elounda.  All three properties are much more expensive in the combined program.  I also hope to take advantage of the fact that top-tier SPG properties, including off-the-charts properties, will cost no more than 60,000 points per night (or 48K per night thanks to 5th night free) until both category 8 and peak-season pricing are introduced in early 2019.

My plan, as described in the post “Biding my Marriott time before returning to Hyatt,” has been to return to Hyatt starting January 2020.  I would then make use of the World of Hyatt credit card in order to help achieve top tier Globalist elite status.  That card offers 5 elite nights per year automatically, plus 2 additional elite nights for each $5K of spend.  Globalist status requires 60 elite nights initially, and then 55 elite nights per year to re-qualify.

Why bother at all?  In my opinion, more so than any other hotel chain, Hyatt has top tier perks that are worth striving for:

  • 4 suite upgrade awards that can be used at the time of reservation.  Each upgrade award can be used to upgrade an entire stay.  This is huge when booking family vacations where the extra space in a suite can be really important.
  • Free parking on award stays
  • Waived resort fees on paid and award nights (this is huge)
  • Club lounge access or full breakfast for up to 2 guests plus 2 children
  • Guest of Honor bookings lets you share in-hotel perks with others when you book award stays for them.
  • Upgrade at check-in, up to standard suite
  • 4pm late checkout

And then… 5/24 happened

The World of Hyatt card used to be exempt from Chase’s 5/24 rule.  The latest reports, though, suggest that, as of November 13th or so, the 5/24 rule is being applied to the Hyatt card (and maybe a few other cards as well: BA, Iberia, IHG) .

Chase's 5/24 Rule: With most Chase credit cards, Chase will not approve your application if you have opened 5 or more cards with any bank in the past 24 months.

To determine your 5/24 status, see: 3 Easy Ways to Count Your 5/24 Status. An even easier option is to track all of your cards for free with Travel Freely.

Currently, I’m way over 5/24, and I don’t yet have the World of Hyatt card.  So, is all Hyatt hope lost for me?

The dates line up perfectly

Here are the cards that I’ve signed up for most recently, including the application date:

I generated this list by viewing my Card Dashboard within Travel Freely. I un-selected business cards and sorted by Date Opened.  The real list is much longer, but I only needed to view recent applications to figure out when I can drop below 5/24.

As you can see above, I signed up for three Amex cards on December 4th 2017.  I need to wait for those three cards to reach 24 months old before I have a chance of being under 5/24.  In general, it’s necessary to wait for the month after the 24 month anniversary.  So, in this case, given that the cards were opened on December 4 2017, I need to wait until January 1, 2020 to apply for new Chase cards.

That’s a happy coincidence given that I previously wrote that my best bet was to start pursuing Hyatt status in January 2020:

For many reasons (as described above), I won’t get started this year.  And, because I’ve already planned a number of Marriott/SPG stays for next year, it wouldn’t make much sense to do it then either.  My best bet is to start January 2020.

Can I do it?

If I want to get a World of Hyatt card in January 2020, I can only sign up for one more card between now and then.  That is, I can get only one more card that shows up on my credit report.  Most business cards do not appear as accounts on personal credit reports (Capital One is a big exception to this rule — their business cards do show up).

So, I can sign up for as many business cards as I want (but not from Capital One) and just one personal card between now and January 2020.  If I sign up for more than one, then I’ll still have 5 or more new accounts on my credit report that are 24 months old or less.

Among the cards that are currently available, there’s only one consumer card I’m eager to get: The Bank of America Premium Rewards Card:

Bank of America Premium Rewards

FM Mini Review: This card has best-in-class earnings for those with $100K+ invested with BOA. With that level of investment, you would earn 3.5X travel & dining and 2.62X everywhere else.


Annual Fee: $95

Card Type: Visa Signature

Base
1.5X
(1.5%)
Travel
Dine

Earning rate: ⚬ 2X travel and dining ⚬ 1.5X everywhere else

Noteworthy perks: ⚬ $100 annual airline incidentals fee reimbursement ⚬ Up to 75% bonus for Preferred Rewards banking customers

I discussed the Premium Rewards card in the post “Super Combos Cash Back Credit Cards.”  If you can get Platinum Honors Preferred Rewards status with Bank of America, this is a truly incredible cash back card.  I could get this card and still be under 5/24 by January 2020.

Of course, I don’t want to miss out on other great card offers that appear over the next 13 months.  For those, though, my wife and/or son could apply.

What about authorized user cards?

I am an authorized user on a number of accounts not shown above.  As a result, even when I dip under 5/24 based on my own accounts, my Chase applications will still be rejected.  The workaround is to call and explain that I’m just an authorized user and not responsible for that credit.

Should I do it?

There is definitely a cost to staying under 5/24.  I’ll risk missing out personally on great card offers (even though my wife and son could still take advantage of them).

A bigger risk is the unknown.  It’s possible… likely even… that a card issuer will introduce a new card that I’ll really want.  In many such cases, I could simply have my wife sign up and add me as an authorized user in order to make use of the new card.  But, in some cases, the most attractive perks (whatever they are) may be reserved only for the primary cardholder.

My plan

I’m going to try to get under 5/24 by January 2020.  I can safely sign up for one more consumer card (or Capital One business card) between now and then.  That one card will probably be the Bank of America Premier Rewards card.  That said, I’m going to wait a while before applying.  It won’t surprise me at all if something more exciting appears in the interim.

If I manage to drop under 5/24 by January 2020, then I’ll sign up for the Chase World of Hyatt card and begin my quest for Globalist status.  It’s not entirely rational: most perks can be had by asking a friend with Globalist status to book my award stays as Guest of Honor reservations.  But, I find it fun having a goal like this to strive towards.

Note: I’ll probably apply for a second Chase card (probably a business card) at the same time to take full advantage of being momentarily under 5/24.

View from our Ocean View Townhouse at the Hyatt Carmel Highlands

About Greg The Frequent Miler

Greg is the owner, founder, and primary author of the Frequent Miler. He earns millions of points and miles each year, mostly without flying, and dedicates this blog to teaching others how to do the same.

More articles by Greg The Frequent Miler »

34
Leave a Reply

avatar
15 Comment threads
19 Thread replies
17 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
18 Comment authors
PJ RizzGreg The Frequent MilerMike HuangKunalBiggie F Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
Notify of
Kate
Guest
Kate

Good luck, hope it works for you! I find Hyatt’s footprint so limited, it definitely wouldn’t make sense for me. I don’t want to be choosing my travel destinations based on hyatt locations. To make matters worse, sometimes even when there is a Hyatt, it’s not as well located as the Hilton where I can buy diamond status with the Aspire. ( But I did enjoy my one year of the old hyatt Diamond with the status match a few years ago. ) And I’ll all about going for credit cards now as the rules tighten more and more. Who knows what restrictions are around the corner?

Belinda
Guest
Belinda

Yes…for me Hyatt is too limited in locations. However I have been doing less domestic travel lately…so do most large international cities have Hyatt’s? I’ll have to check. I do love their elite perks you mentioned…4 suite upgrades at checkin, no resort fees or parking charges! Wow! My friend who worked the front desk at Conrad Tokyo asked me what perks Diamonds received at say a Hampton Inn…I’m like well more points and a reserved parking forDiamonds sign near the front door. Kinda embarrassing actually. I’m closing in on lifetime status though 862/1000 nights. I’ll be locked in to that fabulous parking space real soon

PedroNY
Guest
PedroNY

A year flies by when you have business cards fun. Just a reminder being an AU on some cards will show up as new acct on your report, I know that you know that, and that calling Chase can override it as long as you are under 5/24 w/o AUs, just a friendly reminder.

Cheers,

PedroNY

Danielle
Guest
Danielle

Andaz Papagayo Costa Rica should be 15,000 points for a free night, not 25,000.

Pat
Guest
Pat

United Passes are not longer a Hyatt Globalist Perk as of Dec. 31 2018.

Blue
Guest
Blue

I’m cooling down my report a bit and the approach I am taking is to hit P2 harder and add/subtract myself as an AU to double hit minimum spends. Plus some biz cards of course.

DSK
Guest
DSK

Greg–IMHO your blog has the best ANALYSIS of anyone else out there. You can tear into and analyze a loyalty program better than anyone else can and it was a pleasure speaking with you at FTU. So please help me understand this Hyatt infatuation.

I literally just crossed the threshold for lifetime Marriott Platinum Premier elite and receive Diamond status in Hilton through the credit card (now it is easy–earlier it required $40K of spend annually). I was Hyatt Diamond for two years and have been Explorist for two years (thanks to you and Nick). I have stayed in plenty of Hyatt suites around the world and also have the new WOH credit card. But, as others have mentioned, the Hyatt footprint is so small, and I found myself during my Hyatt Diamond years planning my trips around where I could find a Hyatt with an executive lounge (which is probably among the most important desires for me travelling internationally). If you look at the Hyatt footprint and delete all of the hotels without lounges, you now have a really, really small footprint. On the other hand, there are Marriotts/Starwoods and Hiltons literally everywhere, and it is easy to find one with an executive lounge in the USA or abroad. My upgrade success has been very good with both, and surprisingly especially with Marriott post-integration. Also, a pretty significant subset of those Hyatt hotels with suites don’t work well with families (particularly my family of five). Furthermore, when I am looking just for a side-if-the-road hotel for a road trip (in at 8 pm and out at 8 am), the Hyatt footprint is pitiful compared with Marriott and Hilton. I haven’t really found that I have been treated generally any better or worse at Hyatts than at Marriots or Hiltons–it really depends on the hotel. I don’t dislike Hyatts at all and will continue to stay at them when they meet my needs.

It is a MAJOR commitment to get to Globalist. Is it really worth it to go out of your way for that many nights per year compared with Marriott and Hilton hotels that will probably treat you fairly well and might also be in a better location for you? Your upgrade rates (including to suites) should be pretty good at Marriott at the Platinum Premier elite level and also decent at the Hilton Diamond level. It is a lot easier to find 35 Marriott nights per year (which gets you lounge access with a credit card) compared to 55/60 Hyatt nights. Genuinely curious given this your usual level of analysis.

Ian
Guest
Ian

No, no, no, no. Do not put other cards on hold, particularly for a whole year, just to get under 5/24. For all we know by this time next year many other banks will have adopted a 5/24-esque rule and you will have wasted precious time to sign up for their cards just for…. a Hyatt card? With all due respect, no.

If there’s anything I’ve learned in this hobby, it’s to jump on things you can now, there is no planning for that far in the future. The landscape changes too quickly.

P T
Guest
P T

When I was at 4/24 a couple of years back, I was an AU on two other cards. Multiple calls to Chase were of no avail. One of them was while sitting in front of my Chase Personal Banker. Good luck Greg!

Texan@heart
Guest
Texan@heart

I’m with DSK and Ian on this. The rules of this game change too fast. And lately, they’re changing in the wrong direction. I was in a similar boat– I have Marriott Platinum status at least until 2020 and was considering bailing out to chase Globalist. However, the limited Hyatt footprint proved to be a deal killer: There just aren’t Hyatt’s near all of our company’s offices across the country, whereas Hiltons and Marriotts are often literally within walking distance.

I pick up at least 20-30 nights a year from business travel. Getting to Globalist without that would be a MAJOR commitment and expense on my own dime. But beyond my own personal circumstances, I fail to see how the Globalist juice is worth the squeeze.

One of the best pieces of insight on this blog is that free agency is the way to go unless you’re confident about hitting the top tier. A free agent can buy nearly all of the Globalist benefits on any given stay with Chase UR or Hyatt points. They may not come cheaply, but they can be had (with the exception of the 4:00 PM checkout).

Finally, I must be one of the few people on the planet who has been pleasantly surprised by Starriott post-merger. I’ve been scoring some great room/suite upgrades at Marriott properties since August. Maybe it’s dumb luck. Or maybe it’s because the Amex Platinum card no longer buys 50-night status and the herd is thinning.

DSK
Guest
DSK

Ditto. Thought it was just me. Getting much better upgrades, including suite upgrades, post August 2018 with Marriott.

Miles Ahead
Guest
Miles Ahead

Do you have the existing Hyatt card? I just upgraded mine last summer– yeah, I only got 2k points for the upgrade it, but I have been finding ‘creative ways to spend’, on the card largely thanks to your’s and docs blogs. Between my stays and spend, I made Explorist this year, and while Explorist in itself is nothing exciting, getting another free night for obtaining it was, which translated to $425 value for a stay over New Years, so between the points earned on spend and obtaining status to get another free night just for obtaining Explorist was a nice win. So, yeah, I did not get 60K points, and you might not either if you just upgrade (assuming you have the old hyatt card), but with the way you earn UR points on your chase business cards is this really an issue (you can always transfer UR to Hyatt as you well know)??
I am on the fence about spending to obtain globalist. I do not currently have any other hotel elite statuses (but am gold Hilton, Marriott, plat wyndham) and my goal is ALWAYS free stays over elite perks, since I do not travel for biz. In spite of their more limited footprint, Hyatt is my fave hotel chain by a long shot and I am glad to see them grow with Two Roads acquisition and Small Luxury Hotels partnership. Maybe more down the road? It might just make me want to spend and stay to Globalist. If only I had even more time to travel! 🙂

Ian
Guest
Ian

This smacks of “waiting around a year for a boy/girl you like to like you back”, only to see them end up with someone else after a year of waiting, and seeing the boy/girl who liked you all along (Citi…) find someone else too.

P-nope
Guest
P-nope

My sister achieved Explorist status and received the lounge access awards, but the hotels we looked at available at we’re planning to stay in the next year only offer continental breakfast. Not even worth it and that’s only explorist status. We don’t care about the other “benefits” of globalist to even bother. I can get continental breakfast by being a Hilton member and just getting one of their credit cards.

JustSaying
Guest
JustSaying

Next card statement will give me the additional 4 nights to make Globalist with only 13 award nights and no paid nights. The reason I went for it is a European vacation that includes Park Hyatt in Paris and Milan. Then in between you have the new Small Luxury Hotels of the World and they all over France and Italy and I fully expect to spend 6 weeks in their properties so I am thinking Globalist will come in handy. The other hotels status are chump change next to Hyatt if luxury stays are your goal. That is mine and why I spent on the card.

Kunal
Guest
Kunal

Given all the changes Chase has been making and also considering how fast things change in this space its kinda moot trying to be under 5/24. There is a long time between now and Jan 2020 and who knows what would happen so it doesn’t make much sense to plan that far. IMO Chase 5/24 was already overrated and now they have made my decision much easier to build a portfolio with other rewards program.

Mike Huang
Guest
Mike Huang

I think even if you apply for Chase Business card, they will still count your are over 5/24.

PJ Rizz
Guest
PJ Rizz

Why haven’t you got around to applying for the World of Hyatt card when you heard rumors of it being subject to 5/24?