Should everyone open two Chase Southwest cards?

This morning, Greg wrote about planning your Chase application strategy (See: The best Chase cards that ARE subject to 5/24 rule). A few months ago, standing on the cusp of 5/24, my wife opened two of those cards — two Southwest Airlines credit cards — in order to earn herself a Southwest Companion Pass with her final Chase slots for the next couple of years. Should that be everyone’s strategy?

January 2017 Month in Review

Here’s what really prompted the title question: Greg also recently posted the latest update in our series about Ben, a well-informed newbie, and his journey opening his first rewards cards (See: 600,000 points and well under 5/24). In response to Ben’s growing portfolio of cards, a reader asked:

I am curious why the Southwest personal and business cards were not included Greg because you can earn a Companion pass for the remainder of this year and all of next which is a valuable asset by getting those cards. What are your thoughts on working those in and what would you replace?

I totally agree that the Companion Pass is a great value. In fact, I’ve often said that in my opinion it’s the best deal in domestic travel.

However, not everyone lives near an airport that’s well served by Southwest (my parents live 10 minutes from their nearest airport, but about 2.5hrs from the nearest airport served by Southwest). Not everyone enjoys the open seating policy (my wife hates not knowing where we’ll sit). Not everyone travels in pairs (I’ve traveled alone to FTU events a number of times in the past year). Further, if you travel for work regularly enough to qualify for elite status, you may prefer flying on the airline with which you’ve earned those benefits (Greg’s got Delta Diamond status and has gotten many upgrades over the years). Some people just won’t travel domestically often enough for it to make sense, or they live near an airport that often has cheap economy fares to the places they’d like to go. In a nutshell, Southwest isn’t for everyone. Personally, I rarely ever fly domestically on anyone other than Southwest thanks in part to the Companion Pass, but the relative value to each person can vary.

Southwest Companion Pass without flying

I love Southwest….but that doesn’t mean everyone should.

I think there are plenty of good reasons not to go after the Southwest Companion Pass. And if you’re not going to try for the Southwest Companion Pass, it’s not a good choice to open the Southwest cards. Even if you might fly Southwest now and then, it would be more worthwhile to focus on Ultimate Rewards cards. They are also subject to 5/24 and Ultimate Rewards points could transfer to Southwest if you really wanted to book a Southwest flight on points. You’d be better off focusing on the 80K signup bonus for the Chase Ink Business Preferred or the 65K current bonus on the Chase Sapphire Preferred or the 55K on the Chase Sapphire Reserve. If you finish with those, I think the earning potential and no-annual-fee of a Chase Ink Cash or Chase Freedom / Freedom Unlimited make them more valuable to have in your wallet than a Southwest card in the long run.

Since the Southwest cards earn 1x on non-Southwest purchases and each point is only worth about 1.6 cents towards Wanna Get Away fares, it wouldn’t make sense to open these cards and spend on them regularly in most situations. So while I agree that the Companion Pass is an incredibly valuable benefit that I use frequently, I think that beauty is in the eye of the beholder — the Southwest Companion Pass just isn’t for everyone.

About Nick Reyes

Nick Reyes is a (fairly) regular guy with an animalistic passion for maximizing the value of miles and money to travel the world in comfort and style. There is little in life that he loves more than finding a fantastic deal and helping you shop smarter & harder to achieve your travel dreams.

More articles by Nick Reyes »

9
Leave a Reply

avatar
5 Comment threads
4 Thread replies
4 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
7 Comment authors
Nick ReyesJoshNick ReyesJamesCaveDweller Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
Notify of
Alli
Guest
Alli

Can I product change Southwest personal cards to UR earning personal cards?

Jeff
Guest
Jeff

They used to allow this but it seems those days are over.

Gene
Guest
Gene

If you want to be stuck in coach, sure. I’ll save my 5/24 for something better than WN.

CaveDweller
Guest
CaveDweller

My Doc saved $6500 with the companion pass in one year perfect deal IF it works for u ..I wonder how that open seating will work on a MDW>HNL as in no thanks .Years ago their prices were the best today they just have a few sweet spots .
I’m an Inker transfer to lots of airlines SW card just one.
CHEERs

James
Guest
James

I have a business southwest card that I opened last January 2017. I was planning on opening a Personal southwest card this month to try to get companion pass again. Here is my question, will the 5/24 rule affect me if I do this? Or will I still be able to get the $40,000 bonus points? Thanks!

Josh
Guest
Josh

Would it make sense to cancel one southwest card (plus) so I can apply for the other (premier) and get another bonus?